Beeps Pizza: Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Afton, WY with Perfect Crust & Flavor

Just off the main drag in Afton - right at the Elk Antler Arch, is a small alley with a great coffee shop with a fantastic pizza joint next door. The pizza has one of those perfect NY style crusts - thin and crunchy with a soft chewy texture. Topped by a flavorful sauce emphasizing the flavor of the tomatoes and then covered with a generous portion of cheeses. The pizza was fantastic. Just remember to buy some cookies while you are there. You’ll thank me.

I spend quite a bit of time in NY for business and this shop puts out authentic NY pizza with quality ingredients. You can tell that the owners know pizza and love what they do. I will be back for sure!

This place is SO GOOD. My wife and I went here because we always have pizza night on Saturdays and we were not disappointed at all!! The sauce was delicious and the classic pepperoni was just wonderful. They also serve beer there so I got an IPA and it was also excellent! Definitely make sure to get the cheesy garlic bread - I was skeptical at first but after eating it, it’s totally worth it! There aren’t a ton of tables indoors (we went in October) but there are some outside that will make it better to go when it’s warmer out. We would definitely come back!

Wow, absolutely loved this place! The pizza was perfect, we each had a slice - one ricotta and hot honey, one pepperoni and hot honey. The crusts were so lovely and doughy and both had great flavours. They also offer full pizzas but great you can get a single slice if just stopping by. They had Dr Browns soda bought in from New York too which was a great touch. Staff were absolutely lovely!! Moved from New York so you know it’s a proper pizza! Must go to if you’re in the area.

This is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. We got a slice of pepperoni with hot honey and a chocolate chip cookie. I will forever be thinking about how no other pizza can stand up to this one. Wonderful staff to boot! Worth the stop.

Man, listen… I don’t know what kind of angel moved from New York to Afton, Wyoming with a dream and a dough recipe, but bless their heart. This pizza? This pizza got me feeling like I’m cheating on every other meal I’ve ever had. Rolled in with a mission to feed my buddy Paul who, by the way, eats like a bear that just got outta a sugar detox. And don’t even get me started on the twelve ranch dips. Yeah. Twelve. That ain’t a typo, that’s a lifestyle. The crust was so thin and crispy it could’ve voted Republican, and the cheese stretch? Bro, it looked like it went to yoga twice a week and still had commitment issues. I bit into a slice and immediately remembered my childhood, even though I’m not from New York. Look if you’re within 50 miles of Afton and not stopping here, you’re basically committing a felony against your own tastebuds.

The pizza is AMAZING! It is delicious and doesn't bloat you like some of the chain pizza places might. The owners are nice and know what they're doing - everything is made in house. The dough is not shipped in.

We’re in town for the weekend and tried Beeps Pizza for the first time. The pizza is fantastic!! The crust has the perfect texture, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese ties it all together. The garlic bread deserves its own shout out as well! It’s easily the best we’ve had. We’ll definitely be ordering again before heading back home.